"Can you post a side-by-side pic of the two"
Short answer: No
Long answer: In the 20+ yrs that I have made and sold close to 250 of my GT lids, I have not come across nor ever used the larger size sold by 914 Rubber. And of the close to 500 stock grills that I have used to make the GT lids, very few, maybe 5%ish, still had the stock trim still attached.
When they are is good shape and have no rust due to the inbedded metal insert, I have cleaned them up and sold them.
Attached is a pic of a stock trim.
Click to view attachment